Muslim Lantern’s (Muhammad Ali) lies on the True Islam Ahmadiyya

04 Feb, 2023 Allegations on Jama'at-e-Ahmadiyya 0

Table of Contents

Introduction

Muslim Lantern/Muhammad Ali (@Chainless_Slave on Twitter) uploaded a video where he lies about numerous beliefs of Ahmadi Muslims. We made a thread exposing those lies and invited him to discuss with us. He hasn’t responded so far.

1) AHMADIS DON’T DISCUSS?

Ali claims that no Ahmadi Muslim ever discusses with him. They never come back after the first encounter. This is the same experience on our side. Non-Ahmadis do the same. We would be happy to talk to you. Our DMs are open. You can tag us as well.

2) BELIEF IN REINCARNATION?

Ali says that we believe that Promised Messiah AS was the reincarnation of Isa/Krishna AS. This is far from the truth.

We don’t believe in it. Ahmad AS wrote against this concept numerous times while refuting the Hindus.¹

3) CHANGE QURAN TRANSLATION?

A very gross statement from a person of his caliber. On the contrary, we can show how his scholars change the Quranic translation to fit their agenda.

Quran 5:116-117 and Quran 3:55 are just 2 examples.

4) QURAN 61:6 REFERS TO AHMAD AS?

Ali says that we don’t believe the verse is referring to Muhammad ﷺ but only Ahmad AS. This is another lie.

We believe it refers to Muhammad ﷺ. Although we believe it ALSO applies to Ahmad AS as a secondary meaning due to 62:3-4.²

5) AHMADI = FOLLOWER OF GHULAM AHMAD AS?

Ali lies that we call ourselves Ahmadis as it is the name of Ahmad AS.

Ahmadis = Follower of Ahmad ﷺ. This has been explained by the Promised Messiah AS and his Khulafa numerous times.³

6) LAST BRICK = LAST PROPHET?

– Ali believes Isa AS will come AFTER Prophet ﷺ & will be the last prophet to die, do his mission etc.

– Hadith is talking about the superiority of Prophet ﷺ & not about him being last. Musnad Ahmad, Ibn Hajr & Ibn Khuldun refutes him.https://twitter.com/DiscordIslam/status/1621539347735654400

7) 30 DAJJAL = AHMAD AS IS A LIAR?

Ali says that Ahmad AS is one of those false prophets.

He forgets that the ahadith also mention the coming of a prophet (Messiah) and that this hadith was fulfilled long before him AS.⁴

8) ISA AS RETURNS AS A NON-NABI?

Ahadith mention the coming of a prophet in the latter days. Isa AS is called Nabi 4x in a single hadith

Imam Suyti takfirs anyone who says he AS won’t return as a prophet. Even his Salafi/Najdi scholars agree with it⁵

8) ISA AS WON’T LEAD?

Ali says that Isa AS won’t lead the ummah but the Mahdi will.

Numerous ahadith talk about Isa AS leading the Muslims, even in salat.

Ahadith also mention that the Masih is Imam Mahdi.⁶

9) HADITH: 72 VS 1

Ali doesn’t answer which sect is true & quotes ahadith which talks about a Jama’ah (united community) and giving bayah to the Khalifa.

Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’ah is that community that has a Khalifa and is upon the way of Sahaba (RA).⁷

9.1) DEATH WITHOUT IMAM = DEATH OF JAHILLIYAH

Thus, other Muslims must give Bayah to the Khalifa and turn away from all the sects as per the commandment of the Prophet ﷺ so they don’t die the death of Jahiliyah.⁸

CONCLUSION

We request Muhammad Ali (@Chainless_Slave) research before making such misleading statements in his videos.

Since he requested, we are available to discuss any of these topics with him

We hope he accepts this offer so that he can learn more about us. Inshallah!

🧵 Response to Muslim Lantern (@Chainless_Slave)

Muhammad Ali uploaded a video in which he misrepresents the beliefs of Ahmadi Muslims. Although he is respectful, but it is still not a good sign from a famous Da'i

In this short thread, we will address some of those points

1/
— True Islam Discord (@DiscordIslam) February 3, 2023

Have a Question?